“ Can't praise this place enough ! Although basic and somewhat pricey , their pies have such a delicious crust, that you'll remember and crave again and again!. (As we have been doing for at least the past 10 years.) ”

“ Was in Rhinebeck for the day, and we are always on the lookout for excellent pizza. Had good reviews already, so that was encouraging. We were seated right near the pizza making station, and was a very chill relaxed vibe. We met Patrick the owner shorty after and he was chatty and super nice, and knowledgable. We ordered a salad w grilled eggplant and greens. Great dressing. Then onto the Pizza, we orderd the margarita, and was immediately impressed by the look, and smell!!! The pie was expertly cooked, good char and crisp, but not burnt, the cheese was melted perfectly. Patrick mentioned they use 3 cheeses actually, and was one of the most flavorful Neo pies we have tried, and there has been many. Look forward to coming back, and trying more of the menu. GO! ”

“ Our first time in Kingston and saw this on yelp! It's a cute place but not very spacious if you go during busy times. Do not drink the tap water - it tasted horrible like sewage water. So we ordered a bottle of their aqua panna which tasted like water (nothing amazing just water - at least not like their tap). We also got a diet soda which comes in the tiny 8oz glass bottles; if you get a regular coke they come in the larger glass bottles but for diet it only comes in this small one. We got the arugula salad (9/10) - I don't usually like fruits in my salads but the apple slices were the perfect touch to lessen the sourness of the vinaigrette - it was a great salad and a good portion for the table with pizza or by itself for one; note it has goat cheese which I love but some may not. The Margherita pizza with pepperoni (10/10) is what I would go to order again for pizza; even without the pepperoni. We also got the Ponte vecchio (7/10) pizza which has no tomato sauce and mostly has ricotta instead - I didn't really like this as it was very heavy on the bacon and wasn't as clean tasting as the Margherita and was on the heavy side but for those who love bacon, it may be one to consider. Note that the pizzas are not a usual large size but is more for a single person (it is a little bigger than a usual individual pie size) if this was all they were eating. For a family of 5 where 3 were kids under 11yrs - 2 pies and the salad was just the perfect amount. ”

“ We enjoyed a quiet lunch at Pizzeria Posto. It is kind of hard to find if you're not familiar with Rhinebeck. It shows an address on Market St but you need to enter an alley to a little courtyard shopping area, not visible from the street. If it were, I think the place would be full, that's how cozy and inviting the space is. My daughter and I shared the Mediterranean Salad, featuring roasted eggplant, tomatoes, greens and ricotta salita, a Margarita pizza and two glasses of red wine. Everything was made to order, and the salad in particular was fantastic and came with bread and olive oil. The pizza was just what we hoped. I enjoyed watching pizzas being made in a brick oven in the dining room. Afterwards we went two doors over to Bread Alone for a little bite of dessert and coffee. I believe they do have dessert at Pizzeria Posto, although it wasn't offered. ”

“ Wow. As a born and raised local, I cannot believe that I have not heard of this pizzeria sooner. I heard of this place via word of mouth and a friend posting his meal on social media. I thought, that looks amazing. Well, going in person did not disappoint. The shop is in the heart of Rhinebeck, easy parking and conveniently located. Service was very friendly, and it is amazing to have seen the owner making the pizzas practically right in front of our table. Service was quick, and we received our order of three pies within about 5-10 minutes. I must say, these were the most beautiful pizza pies I've ever seen. Additionally, this was the best tasting pizza I have ever tried as well. I would absolutely recommend this pizzeria to all locals to try. ”

“ While you might go there for their great oven fired pizza they have the best salad in town! ”

“ Pizzeria Posto is a solid spot for pizza lovers! The crust here is absolutely fantastic--perfectly crisp on the outside with just the right amount of chewiness inside. The toppings are top-notch, too. They tasted super fresh and well-balanced, with each ingredient really shining through. You can tell they use high-quality ingredients. Service-wise, it was smooth and efficient. The staff was friendly and attentive, making sure we had everything we needed without hovering too much. It's the kind of place where you feel well taken care of but still get to enjoy a relaxed meal. If you're looking for a place that nails both crust and flavor, Pizzeria Posto is definitely worth a visit! ”

“ Portnoy undersold this place. This is a mid to high 9 at minimum! Super fast and courteous service. Plenty of seating indoors and outside in a courtyard. Speaking of courtyard, this place is off the main street, when you see an overhang between two buildings that says "Courtyard", make your way through to pizza greatness. Talked to the chef/owner for a bit, great convo about Pizza spots we have all tried across the NY / NJ area (always great to calibrate with Pizza wizards)! Learned a lot about their style too- wood fired but not your double zero, soft and chewy dough/crust that ends up making people leave it behind (side note, in my mind if you don't eat the whole slice, it was not a great pie). Back to the topic: they use American flour so it has a little bite but also can get crispy and hold itself together. I personally love a tiny bit of char on my crust and not on the cheese- this place delivers! Great people, great food. And we walked way bellies full, souls nourished AND with some recommendations back in NJ where we live- how's that for a culinary experience? ”

“ These are Neapolitan style pizzas. If you want pineapple or jalapenos or chicken on your pizza, this is not your spot. If you want a cauliflower crust, you're going to be disappointed. They have perfected a small collection of pies. The ingredients are fresh and high quality. North of New Rochelle and west of New Haven, you're going to have a hard time finding a better crust. The crunch, the char, the chew, the thinness, the flavor; perfect on both pies we ordered. And they have been that consistent every time we have visited. I wish they had a more robust wine selection and more engaged service. But I keep coming back to how consistently good their pizza is. If you're in the mood for a Neapolitan, there's simply nothing better in 100 miles. ”

“ Pizzeria Posto is an excellent option for pizza or salad in the charming village of Rhinebeck. We had initially ordered pizza for take out since we wanted to try it out passing through the area, but wound up dining in since it was in such a charming plaza. The friendly staff were more than happy to accommodate us. The margherita pizza (4.5/5) was delicious. It was a neopolitan style pizza and the ingredients were highly quality. The crust was cooked to chewy perfection, with sauce made of san marzano tomatoes, and fresh mozzarella, with basil leaves for a little bit of flavor accent. Although I wasn't a huge fan of the basil leaves and this wasn't my favorite style of pizza, I was impressed with the great fresh ingredients/flavor such that I'd recommend Pizzeria Posto to others. The wood fired crust is simply delicious and at a quality level you'd be hard pressed to find outside of Italy. The owner/chef thanked us on the way out and seemed genuinely appreciative of our business, so I'm happy to round up and give them one of my rare 5-star pizza reviews. It's definitely worth a stop for a meal when in Rhinebeck. ”